The Image That Disappears

Débora Kaz ·

In November 2023, a video posted on Instagram showed the consequences of an attack at or near Al Shifa Hospital in Gaza. There were wounded adults and children, or people lying motionless on the ground. Meta removed the video automatically. The user appealed, and the appeal was also rejected automatically.

The case changed only after reaching the Oversight Board, the independent body that reviews certain Meta content decisions. The video was restored with a warning about disturbing imagery and an age restriction, but it remained excluded from recommendations. The reviewing body also disagreed with that reduction in distribution.

It came back without returning to exactly the same place.

That difference is what interests me.

We still tend to think about censorship in terms of explicit disappearance. Something is prohibited, removed, hidden. On digital platforms, the situation has become far less obvious. An image can remain published while losing reach, cease to be recommended, disappear from certain searches, or simply reach far fewer people.

It remains stored on some server and yet practically disappears from circulation.

In the Palestinian case, this matters because the images moving through these platforms are not merely “content,” that curiously clean word used to gather almost everything we put on a screen.

They are houses, hospitals, streets, people, journalists, families, artworks, embroidery, documents, maps, old photographs. Records often produced with no historical intention at all, and which change meaning completely when what they showed ceases to exist.

A domestic photograph acquires another weight when the house in the photograph is no longer there. What was everyday life begins to function as memory.

The struggle over Palestinian memory did not begin on Instagram. During the Nakba in 1948, more than 750,000 Palestinians were displaced from their homes, many of them by force. Territories, communities, and family continuities were broken, and photographs, documents, objects, clothing, and keys also came to preserve connections to places that had been lost or made inaccessible.

Decades later, this relationship between material destruction and the survival of images remains very concrete.

By March 2026, UNESCO had confirmed damage to 164 sites of cultural interest in Gaza since October 2023, including historic buildings, religious sites, monuments, museums, and archaeological areas.

When material heritage disappears, the visual record begins to carry more than it carried before.

And we are living through this at a rather strange moment in history. We outsourced an enormous portion of collective memory to private companies with almost no discussion of what we were doing.

There is something profoundly strange about realizing that photographs of the dead, records of war, birthdays, artworks, family archives, and images of destroyed cities depend on the same companies that calculate how many seconds we spend looking at an advertisement.

Instagram was not created to preserve memory. YouTube is not a film archive. Facebook is not a public archive.

Even so, much of what may still be found twenty or fifty years from now is passing through these places today.

And platforms do not merely store images. They interfere with the conditions under which those images circulate.

A 2023 Human Rights Watch investigation documented 1,050 cases of content removal or suppression on Instagram and Facebook. In 1,049 of them, according to the organization, the content involved peaceful expression in support of Palestine. Human Rights Watch notes that this distribution does not necessarily reflect the overall distribution of moderation on the platforms. Across removals, suspended accounts, livestream restrictions, and loss of recommendation, what appears is not only content that disappears, but different degrees of visibility.

In 2026, a report released by 7amleh — The Arab Center for the Advancement of Social Media, developed in partnership with researcher Fabio Cristiano of Utrecht University, analyzed 3,520 cases recorded between 2021 and 2025 on Meta platforms. According to the organization, in nearly 70 percent of the documented cases users were not clearly informed which policy they had allegedly violated.

That figure unsettles me more than the number of removals.

When a publication is removed and an explanation exists, there is at least a decision against which one can react. When it simply loses circulation, when no one can clearly say what happened, the disappearance leaves very little trace.

The report calls this process platformicide: a presence that does not need to be entirely removed in order to be progressively weakened.

But there is a real difficulty in this discussion. Platforms need to moderate content produced during a war.

There is propaganda from armed organizations, incitement, disinformation, extreme imagery, exploitation of victims. Allowing everything to circulate indiscriminately would not be freedom; it would simply exchange one enormous problem for others.

The difficulty begins when someone has to distinguish propaganda from documentation, glorification from denunciation, violence used to celebrate from violence recorded in order to show that it happened.

It is difficult even for people.

Part of this task has been handed to artificial intelligence. But saying that “the AI decided” hides what came before: policies defined by people, system categories, and a confidence threshold that turns prediction into action.

It was this threshold that Meta changed during the war. The company lowered the confidence required from classifiers. In practice, the machine had to be less certain that a violation had occurred in order to remove content. This reduced the risk of allowing prohibited material through and increased the risk of deleting legitimate material.

The machine does not need to understand a war in order to interfere with how it will be seen. It only needs to recognize patterns within the categories it was given.

On YouTube, this tension appeared in another way.

In 2024, Macklemore's music video Hind’s Hall received an 18+ age restriction because it contained brief images of wounded children and destruction in Gaza. According to a WIRED investigation, a second version containing virtually none of those images did not receive the same restriction.

I do not think every form of protection from violent imagery should automatically be called censorship. That would be too easy.

An image can be traumatic and documentary at the same time.

There may be good reasons not to place it before everyone without warning. At the same time, restricting its display changes its circulation. There is no perfectly clean solution to this contradiction, and pretending there is only makes the discussion more comfortable than it really is.

For a long time, we repeated that the internet never forgets.

It forgets.

We store things inside it and hope they will remain available.

A digital archive depends on a company, a server, a format, a search mechanism, a recommendation system, a policy change, a commercial decision. It can cross the planet in seconds and still be extremely fragile.

For Palestinians, this digital fragility is added to a much longer history of dispute over territory, representation, and memory.

Today that memory is also carried in vertical videos, livestreams, journalists' profiles, and photographs published only minutes after an attack. It can reach millions of people and, some time later, become difficult to find without ever having been formally deleted.

I return to the Al Shifa video because we know it was removed, we know someone appealed, and we know it came back.

What we do not know is how many other images never made that journey.

How many were removed without appeal. How many remain online but are practically impossible to find. How many records disappeared together with an account, a phone, or a person.

That count will probably never be made.

Today there is another kind of power over the image: control over the conditions under which it circulates. Who finds it, for how long, with what reach, and after passing through which classifications.

When people, houses, archives, and places disappear, losing the image that records them is losing something a second time.

Sources

• Oversight Board. Al-Shifa Hospital. December 19, 2023.

• Human Rights Watch. Meta’s Broken Promises: Systemic Censorship of Palestine Content on Instagram and Facebook. December 21, 2023.

• UNESCO. Impact on cultural heritage in Gaza. Updated March 25, 2026.

• 7amleh — The Arab Center for the Advancement of Social Media. The Platformicide of Palestine (2021–2025): A Data-Based Analysis of Meta’s Policy Application, Moderation Enforcement, and Communication. June 9, 2026.

• WIRED. YouTube’s Rulings on Gaza War Videos Spark Internal Backlash. July 2, 2024.

• UNRWA. Palestine refugees.