Architectures of Presence

Débora Kaz ·

Before choosing what to show, we choose where to exist. We can use one platform to organize our professional life, another to publish images, and another to say what we probably would not say at a family gathering. We can build a virtual body, follow discussions without participating, or keep an almost empty account used to observe and disappear before someone tries to turn us into content.

This distribution is rarely planned in full. Sometimes it begins out of necessity, habit, or simple social contagion. We create an account because everyone was there. We remain because leaving also requires a decision. Gradually, each environment acquires a function and begins to receive a particular version of us.

Some of these versions complement one another; others barely know each other. There are carefully organized professional profiles beside abandoned personal accounts, spaces of opinion that seem to belong to another person, and images that construct serenity while life outside the frame deals with its usual administrative fire.

On LinkedIn, fragmented trajectories can be reorganized as a path, a set of skills, and a purpose. Instagram favors visual construction, even when there is no face at all. Text-based platforms receive humor, irritation, confrontation, and a spontaneity that, not infrequently, went through three drafts before appearing spontaneous. In metaverses, the fabrication of the body, appearance, and gesture becomes more explicit. In other spaces, it is possible simply to observe, comment occasionally, and preserve a digital existence with almost no biography.

None of these environments produces a single behavior. Different communities can appropriate the same platform in completely different ways. Even so, no one arrives in an empty space. Recognizable ways of speaking, appearing, interacting, and gaining legitimacy already exist there. Whoever enters encounters codes that predate their arrival and begins to deal with them. They may adhere to them, adapt them, ignore them, displace them, or refuse them. The possibilities are not unlimited, although neither are they written in advance.

Understanding the image of the self only as photograph, face, or avatar would also be insufficient. A presence is composed of texts, cultural repertoires, aesthetic choices, ways of responding, and subjects avoided. Silence participates too, although we cannot interrogate it as though it were an especially cooperative witness.

Someone who publishes only landscapes, books, animals, ruins, restaurants, or empty environments is still composing a field through which they will be perceived. They may not be declaring “this is who I am.” Their choice produces a quieter indication: “this is what I place before you.”

Not everything left out was deliberately hidden. Absence can come from protection, forgetfulness, disinterest, lack of language, exhaustion, or simply a lack of desire to publish. The fact that someone does not show their body, family, home, or work does not authorize a minor investigative breakdown about their secrets. Profiles are legible constructions, not psychological examinations with a sepia filter.

What appears, in turn, has been placed into circulation. A publication may be strategic, affective, impulsive, political, aesthetic, or almost automatic. The degree of awareness varies, but some selection has taken place: this sentence, this photograph among the twenty-seven that died with dignity in the phone gallery, this comment now, no comment later.

In this process, there is a presence that is difficult to locate, although it participates in almost everything: the imagined audience.

Before publishing, we do not always think of a specific person. Often, we anticipate a more diffuse gaze, made up of possible judgments. This may look competent, ridiculous, sensitive, pretentious, cultured, superficial, attractive, outdated, aggressive, or overproduced. We may not know exactly who will see it, but we know part of the vocabulary with which we imagine we will be evaluated.

This audience changes according to the environment, the publication, and what one hopes to provoke. It may be an abstract crowd, a professional group, people close to us, a specific community, or someone whose presence we do not even admit we are considering. We begin to observe ourselves through a gaze we attribute to others.

Publishing involves an attempt to orient interpretation. We offer a hypothesis about how we would like to exist in the eyes of others.

That hypothesis can communicate who we believe we are, who we would like to become, and what we hope others will recognize in us. Someone may begin presenting themselves as an artist before receiving recognition. Another person reorganizes a professional profile to make possible a career transition that has not yet happened. Some publish a peaceful life they may be trying to build. A user creates a virtual body capable of expressing desires or subjective dimensions that have not found form in other contexts.

Digital presence therefore participates in a process that combines representation and projection. What we publish also begins to act upon us. Over time, a person may begin to behave according to what they projected, sustain certain ideas, and reorganize their conduct around them. They assume a name, a practice, an appearance, or a position. The profile created to communicate something that already existed begins to interfere with what is still being built.

Behind all these versions, there is no intact identity waiting to be freed from filters and captions. Identity was already relational before the internet. Different bonds, situations, and audiences activate different forms of presence. We do not speak in the same way to a client, a friend, a stranger, a political group, or someone we love. From time to time, however, someone announces this variation as though they had just unmasked civilization.

In digital environments, part of self-presentation remains after the situation has ended. A remark in conversation may disappear or survive only in the memory of those involved. A post remains accessible, resurfaces, is excerpted, searched, and reinterpreted by people who were not imagined as its audience when it was made. Profiles accumulate different times, abandoned versions, revised positions, and images that no longer correspond to how someone sees themselves. The past remains available to future audiences, not always terribly interested in the delicacy of context.

In metaverses, this fabrication gains an especially visible layer. A person creates a virtual body, chooses its appearance, clothing, gestures, and way of occupying space. Then they photograph that body, select the images, and publish them on another network, composing a visual narrative for a representation that already existed before the photograph.

There is a metalanguage of self-representation there. This does not require every profile connected to virtual worlds to display an avatar. Landscapes, objects, empty spaces, digital architecture, and visual repertoires also produce identity. Sometimes someone appears precisely through the way they remove the body from the scene.

There are also people who construct presences with no biographical correspondence to the identity by which they are known outside that environment. They invent bodies, names, stories, and modes of existence in order to explore desires, live fantasies, temporarily escape certain limitations, or realize dimensions of themselves that have not found form in other contexts.

Not every fictional experience requires someone to continually explain its relationship to the identity lived outside that space. Invention can be play, shelter, aesthetic experience, and a form of realization. It is almost never neutral in relation to the person who produces it. Even without reproducing biographical facts, it carries that person's desires, conflicts, and possibilities.

There is still a concrete person sustaining that presence. Ethical and legal implications remain when fantasy is used to manipulate other people, disregard consent, obtain advantages, or cause concrete harm.

Invention itself can also become rigid. A narrative maintained for a long time demands coherence, new explanations, and sometimes further inventions capable of protecting the earlier ones. A person does not need to literally believe everything they have created in order to begin reorganizing relationships and behaviors around that construction. Without some distance, it becomes harder to recognize its implications and confront the contradictions that arise.

An invented identity can reveal something true without being biographically true. The desire that moves it, the need it answers, and the effects it produces belong to the person who sustains it. When it is no longer confronted by the person who created it, that construction begins to participate in their choices in ways the person may not even recognize.

There are also presences built through reduced exposure. Even without a name, photograph, or biography, someone chooses where to enter, when to speak, what language to use, what subjects to address, when to remain silent, and what traces to leave. They may construct a kind of avatar of absence, made of few accounts, ordinary names, occasional participation, and little interest in turning life into daily programming.

It would be tempting to romanticize this disappearance as political resistance. There may be critique and self-protection, as well as generational difference, temperament, exhaustion, or no grand explanation at all. Not every silent person is conducting sophisticated guerrilla warfare against the attention economy. Some simply do not want to post lunch, and they may be right.

The versions distributed across environments can also come into conflict. Someone tries to communicate simplicity while constantly publishing signs of social distinction. They seek spontaneity through a rigidly calculated aesthetic. They defend independence and organize every gesture around approval. They sustain a political discourse incompatible with the way they treat people. They appear indifferent while obsessively monitoring reception.

Reducing all of this to falseness would be comfortable and imprecise. There are differences between intention and communication, barely conscious habits, internalized values, real conflicts, and distinct functions assigned to each space. The person themselves does not completely know the image they produce.

Some distance always remains between what we intend to communicate and what we put into the world. We can edit a presence without controlling all of its readings or perceiving all the patterns we repeat. Themes, poses, affects, indignations, and forms of distinction reappear without asking permission. While we construct one version, others escape at the edges. Perfect coherence across every environment might look less like integrity and more like an exceptionally well-managed brand.

These choices also take place under unequal conditions. Platforms make some behaviors more visible, recognizable, and rewarded. We arrive with differences in time, money, repertoire, technical skill, and networks of contacts. Some people are there for pleasure; others depend on exposure in order to work. Some publish because they want to appear, and others because disappearing has become professionally unviable.

This structure becomes more perceptible when we observe its everyday effects. Over time, we learn which images receive more attention and begin producing them more often. Certain opinions are abandoned because they circulate poorly. A work that took months seems less valuable than a post made in minutes, as long as the latter produces the expected reaction. Gradually, it may become difficult to separate one's own desire from what we learned to desire because it is visible, recognized, and rewarded.

Users transform functions, create unlikely communities, invent languages, and occupy platforms in ways their creators did not foresee. Even refusal can be read according to codes that were already there.

This movement is not limited to fictional identities. We can begin by selecting images to represent a life and gradually begin selecting the life that best sustains those images. A position adopted in order to produce recognition begins to demand repetition. The search for belonging teaches the individual to desire what the environment knows how to reward. Certain parts of experience gain value because they are publishable; others seem smaller because they offer no image, narrative, or response.

The architectures of presence then cease to organize only what we show. They interfere with what we recognize as beauty, intelligence, success, relevance, and truth about ourselves. They were built through partial choices, habits, desires, and structures that existed before our arrival. We continue acting within them, although we cannot always perceive the moment when their criteria began to feel natural.

We think we are choosing the image. We do not always notice when we begin living in order to sustain it.

References for verification

DEVITO, Michael Ann; BIRNHOLTZ, Jeremy; HANCOCK, Jeffrey T. “Platforms, People, and Perception: Using Affordances to Understand Self-Presentation on Social Media”. In: Proceedings of the 2017 ACM Conference on Computer Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing. New York: Association for Computing Machinery, 2017, pp. 740–754.

GOFFMAN, Erving. The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. New York: Anchor Books, 1959.

HOGAN, Bernie. “The Presentation of Self in the Age of Social Media: Distinguishing Performances and Exhibitions Online”. Bulletin of Science, Technology & Society, vol. 30, no. 6, 2010, pp. 377–386.

LITT, Eden; HARGITTAI, Eszter. “The Imagined Audience on Social Network Sites”. Social Media + Society, vol. 2, no. 1, 2016, pp. 1–12.

MADIANOU, Mirca; MILLER, Daniel. “Polymedia: Towards a New Theory of Digital Media in Interpersonal Communication”. International Journal of Cultural Studies, vol. 16, no. 2, 2013, pp. 169–187.

SCOLERE, Leah; PRUCHNIEWSKA, Urszula; DUFFY, Brooke Erin. “Constructing the Platform-Specific Self-Brand: The Labor of Social Media Promotion”. Social Media + Society, vol. 4, no. 3, 2018, pp. 1–11.